Frommer's Review
Overlooking the Great Sound, this restaurant offers a diverse menu that pleases diners who aren't too demanding. If you want filling and satisfying food, it's a suitable choice, though it's not quite as fun a spot as The Frog & Onion Pub. The seating, at pine tables and chairs, is comfortable, and the serving staff (costumed as pirates) is helpful. It's a little hokey, but everyone seems to get into the "pirate-esque" spirit, especially after a rum punch or two. For the most part, the standard lunch fare -- soups, burgers, pastas, and grilled specialties -- is adequate, but not special. However, the gyros on pita bread are spicy delights, especially the 7-inch gyro pizza made with fresh vegetables, pepperoni, and mozzarella.
At night the kitchen shines more brightly, as the chefs look abroad for inspiration. Two of the finest dishes are beef tenderloin with porcini mushrooms and chicken cacciatore. Pastas, made fresh daily, are quite delicious. We are less devoted to the garlic shrimp and fresh fisherman's grill.
Note: This information was accurate when it was published, but can change without
notice. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before
planning your trip.