Myths of Bimini
These islands have long been shrouded in myths, none more far-fetched than the one claiming that the lost continent of Atlantis lies off the shores of North Bimini. This legend grew because of the weirdly shaped rock formations that lie submerged in about 6m (20 ft.) of water near the shoreline. Pilots flying over North Bimini have reported what they envision as a "lost highway" under the sea. This myth continues, and many scuba divers are attracted to North Bimini to explore these rocks.
Ponce de León came to South Bimini looking for that celebrated Fountain of Youth. He never found it, but people still come to South Bimini in search of it. Near the end of the 19th century, a religious sect reportedly came here to "take the waters" -- supposedly a bubbling fountain or spring. If you arrive on South Bimini and seem interested enough, a local guide (for a fee) will be happy to show you "the exact spot" where the Fountain of Youth once bubbled.