Frommers.com Frommers.com
Most Recent Shelter Island Forum Posts
Most Recommended Articles
Most Commented Articles

Sweet Tomato's Frommer's Very Highly Recommended

15 Grand Ave, Shelter Island, NY

Frommer's ReviewMap It
Cuisine American
Hours July to Labor Day Mon-Fri from 5pm, Sat-Sun from noon; rest of the year Tues-Sun from 5pm
Location Around Town
Phone 631/749-4114
Prices Main courses $14-$30
Credit Cards AE, DC, DISC, MC, V

Sweet Tomato's Review

This eatery in the tiny town of Shelter Island Heights makes for a good dinner stop after antiquing. The Northern Italian menu doesn't present any surprises, but in the bright, cheery restaurant with hardwood floors, the classics are served up nicely. Try the chicken Antonio: chicken breast chunks with sautéed onions and peas in a pink, cognac cream sauce with rigatoni.

Note: This information was accurate when it was published, but can change without notice. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before planning your trip.



Destination Guide
Destination Guide Destination Guide Destination Guide
Destination Guide Destination Guide Frommer's New York State, 5th Edition Destination Guide Frommer's New York State, 5th Edition

Author: Marc Lallanilla
Pub Date: January 03, 2012

Learn More
Destination Guide Destination Guide Destination Guide Related Titles:
AARP Catskill Mountain Region, New York State: ShortCuts
Destination Guide
AARP New York City 2012
Destination Guide
AARP New York State, 5th Edition
Destination Guide
Destination Guide Destination Guide
Destination Guide Destination Guide Destination Guide
Destination Guide
Destinations
Destinations
 
 

Frommer's Star Ratings

Frommer's Recommended 0 stars Frommer's Recommended
Frommer's Highly Recommended 1 stars Frommer's Highly Recommended
Frommer's Very Highly Recommended 2 stars Frommer's Very Highly Recommended
Frommer's Exceptional 3 stars Frommer's Exceptional

About Our System

Frommer's ranks every hotel, restaurant, attraction, shop, and nightlife establishment it reviews for quality, value, service, amenities, and special features using a star-rating scale, an expression of the strong compare-and-contrast opinions that are a brand hallmark.

Other ratings provide stars based primarily on price and amenities; the Frommer's star rating is meant to quantify the kind of intangible, experiential elements that help travelers make informed decisions.

The "baseline" recommendation is zero stars--every hotel, restaurant, attraction, shop, and nightlife establishment that Frommer's chooses to review is recommended; otherwise, we simply wouldn't include it.

Close Window