Home > Destinations > Caribbean and the Atlantic > Caribbean > Virgin Islands > Introduction > Best Dining Bets
Bookstore Travel Talk - Our Message Boards Tips and Tools Book a Trip Deals and News Trip Ideas, Activities, Lifestyles Hotels Destinations Frommers.com Home
Frommer's - The best trips start here. Frommer's - The best trips start here.
Sign up for our FREE Newsletters! Win a FREE Trip
  Email This Article Email Print This Article Print Get Frommer's RSS Feed RSS

Best Dining Bets

  • Tavern on the Waterfront (St. Thomas; tel. 340/776-4328): Every celebrity who visits the U.S.V.I. seems to turn up here. Opening onto harbor views at Charlotte Amalie, this restaurant serves some of the island's finest French and Caribbean cuisine. Imaginative dishes include such treats as espresso-and-cinnamon-encrusted pork medallions with a passion-fruit demi-glaze.

  • Hervé Restaurant & Wine Bar (St. Thomas; tel. 340/777-9703): This establishment, next to the landmark Hotel 1829, has captured loads of attention, and was once featured in Gourmet magazine. The panoramic view is great, but it's the cuisine that is the draw: a truly sublime repertoire of American and Caribbean cuisines. Nothing beats the black sesame-crusted tuna with a ginger and raspberry sauce.

  • Virgilio's (St. Thomas; tel. 340/776-4920): This cheerful, elegant spot boasts the best Italian food on the island. Virgilio's lovingly prepares all your favorite Italian classics (try the osso buco or chicken parmigiana), in addition to more than 20 different homemade pasta dishes, and a few surprises, like cioppino (a kettle of savory seafood stew). Savvy diners always save room for one of the flambé desserts.

  • Asolare (St. John; tel. 340/779-4747): The most beautiful and elegant restaurant on St. John also features some of the island's best food. The chef produces a fusion of French and Asian cuisine that relies on the island's freshest seafood and produce. Try the prawn and coconut milk soup, or the spicy tuna tartare wrapped in noodles. The staff is the hippest and most attractive on the island.

  • Le Château de Bordeaux (St. John; tel. 340/776-6611): Both the view and the exquisite combination of Continental and Caribbean cuisine are winners. Wild game, and rack of lamb perfumed with rosemary and surrounded by a honey-Dijon nut crust, appear often on the ever-changing menu. The West Indian seafood chowder is a perfect blend of fish and spices.

  • The Terrace (St. Croix; tel. 340/773-2100): Housed in the Buccaneer, the most prestigious resort on St. Croix, this is the best hotel restaurant on the island. The first-class cuisine is prepared with quality ingredients. Wait until you try the grilled lobster cakes.

  • Kendricks (St. Croix; tel. 340/773-9199): The married owners at Kendricks bring a light Continental touch to richly flavored dishes. You might begin with baked brie smothered in perfectly seasoned wild mushrooms, then move on to coconut shrimp in a chive-studded, peppery aioli. Some of this culinary couple's recipes have been featured in Bon Appétit magazine.

    The Best Dishes in the Virgin Islands

  • Conch Chowder at Molly Malone's (St. Thomas; tel. 340/775-1270): Island chefs pride themselves on their conch chowder, but Molly has got the other cooks beat. Savory, spicy, perfectly flavored conch chowder is served nightly.

  • Creative Salads at Robert's American Grille (St. Thomas; tel. 340/775-1000): The homemade salads here are the freshest on the island. A delightful treat is the Elysian salad, made with mesclun tossed with roasted walnuts, Bermuda onions, chopped tomatoes, and a house-made dried-cranberry-and-poppy-seed dressing.

  • Sushi at Beni Iguana's Sushi Bar (St. Thomas; tel. 340/777-8744): A rarity in the U.S. Virgin Islands, delectable sushi appears on the menu in the Grand Hotel Court in Charlotte Amalie. Try the big roll stuffed with spicy crabmeat, salmon, and other delights.

  • Callaloo Soup at Miss Lucy's (St. John): Callaloo is a spinachlike vegetable native to the West Indies, and local chefs know how to make one of the island's most satisfying soups from this humble plant. Self-taught Miss Lucy seems to impart a magic touch to her kettle. We always go for a second bowl.

  • Garlic Chicken at Vie's Snack Shack (St. John; tel. 340/693-5033): Some residents of St. Thomas cross the bay just to sample some of Vie's fabled garlic chicken. We don't know exactly what she does with the bird, but it's such a savory concoction that the dish becomes addictive.

  • Succulent Pastas at Zozo's Ristorante (St. John; tel. 340/693-9200): You can enjoy an array of appetizing pastas at one of the finest Italian restaurants in the Virgins. It doesn't get much better than the lobster ravioli with wild mushrooms and toasted pine nuts.

  • Seafood Chowder at Le Château de Bordeaux (St. John; tel. 340/776-6611): Even if you're from New England, you'll savor the West Indian seafood chowder here. The chef uses the freshest fish and just the right spices.

  • Margaritas at Morgan's Mango (St. John; tel. 340/693-8141): Thursday is officially "Margarita Night," but on any night the bartenders will whip up your favorite margarita. Only Jimmy Buffet knows how to do it better.

  • Tantalizing Curries at Savant (St. Croix; tel. 340/713-8666): The spicy dishes of Thailand and Mexico are served at this Christiansted eatery. We always go for the Thai curries, which are as good as some of those served in the mother country. The red coconut curry sauce is among the finest we've ever sampled.

  • Lobster Pasta at the Bombay Club (St. Croix; tel. 340/773-1838): We've never been able to work our way through the menu here, because we always like to fill up on the fresh lobster pasta, which is cooked to perfection and well-seasoned with delectable hunks of fresh lobster.

  • Mahimahi at Round Hill Vacation Villa (Tortola; tel. 284/495-9353): Joycelyn and Allan Rhymer perform wonders with one of our favorite fishes, mahimahi, serving it with a savory garlic-butter sauce.

  • Home-Cooked West Indian Meals at Mrs. Scatliffe's Restaurant (Tortola; tel. 284/495-4556): Mrs. Scatliffe's Restaurant is the domain of everyone's favorite B.V.I. grandmother. She'll feed you the most authentic West Indian cuisine in the B.V.I., including spicy conch soup, curried goat, a white fish called "old wife," and more.

  • Fresh Pumpkin Soup at Skyworld (Tortola; tel. 284/494-3567): In the islands, pumpkin appears on the menu frequently, unlike in the States, where it is most often made into pies at Thanksgiving. Pumpkin soup, an island favorite, is tastier here than anywhere else, and makes you appreciate the much-neglected squash more than ever.

  • The Spareribs at Fat Hog Bob's (Tortola; tel. 284/495-1010): Even if you're from the South, you'll salivate over the ribs served at Fat Hog Bob's. Like all barbecue chefs, the cooks here keep their sauce a secret -- and is it ever tasty.

  • Mud Pie at Pusser's Landing (Tortola; tel. 284/495-4554): Mud pie may appear on many menus, but it's a classic at Pusser's, home of "the rum people." It's so rich that no one ever asks for a second helping. Don't like mud pie? Dig into the mango soufflé.

  • Conch Fritters at Top of the Baths (Virgin Gorda; tel. 284/495-5497): From the Bahamas to Key West, hundreds of chefs proclaim that they make the best conch fritters. We'd like to nominate the cooks at this little eatery for their spicy, delectable fritters, which are a meal unto themselves.

  • The Painkiller at the Soggy Dollar Bar (Jost Van Dyke; tel. 284/495-9888): We can't compete with the yachtsman who drank 10 Painkillers in 1 night, leaving him feeling no pain indeed. But this delectable rum-based drink, whose recipe is a closely guarded secret, gets our vote for the best-tasting rum punch in the B.V.I. Its home is the bar at the Sandcastle.

  • Grilled Swordfish at the Cow Wreck Beach Bar & Grill (Anegada; tel. 284/495-8047): This elegant fish is grilled and flavored to perfection here. "It gets no better," proclaimed one happy diner at the table next to us, and we agree. Our dish was so fresh that the fish must have been just "harvested" from the sea.


    Back to Top


    Note: This information was accurate when it was published, but can change without notice. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before planning your trip.


      Email This Article Email Print This Article Print Get Frommer's RSS Feed RSS
    Frommer's Virgin Islands, 9th Edition Frommer's Virgin Islands, 9th Edition

    Author: Darwin Porter
    Pub Date: August 27, 2007
    Price: $17.99

    Buy Now!
    Related Titles:
    Bahamas For Dummies, 4th Edition
    Caribbean For Dummies, 4th Edition
    Frommer's Bahamas 2008
  • Add Frommers.com RSS Feed  Add Frommers.com RSS Feed (What's This?)
    Add Frommers.com Deals & News to Your Web Site
    Add to My Yahoo!     Add to My MSN     More RSS Readers
    Add Frommers.com Podcast Add Frommers.com Podcast (What's This?)
    Home > Destinations > Caribbean and the Atlantic > Caribbean > Virgin Islands > Introduction > Best Dining Bets