This inn has some of the island's most spacious and lovely rooms. Most have whirlpool tubs, some are dotted with antiques and some have private decks—as well as a lovely porch and water views. And if you don't get one with a view, you can always head to the wrap around porch to watch the sunset. In summer, donuts from the adjacent Payne's Killer Donuts are a legendary local treat (open Memorial Day to Columbus Day daily 7am–7pm). Those same donuts are included in the continental breakfast (and sometimes laid out, free, in the afternoon for guests). We also have to give kudos to the helpful and friendly owner Carol.
- Frommer's Staff