Another charmer of a variation on the Key West theme of historic architecture and a fetching heated pool set amid palmy verdant gardens. Behind a striking, balustraded, triple-decker facade, Island City House also brings a particular distinction to the table: It’s the island’s oldest still-operating guesthouse, established in 1912 from a merchant’s home built in 1880 (if you’re looking for period decor, the original building is the place, with hardwood floors, lace curtains, wainscoting, four-posters, and antiques). Two adjacent, also historic buildings were added and now house half of the units, which lean toward a more contemporary flavor; some, for example, with white pickled-wood paneling, others with a more Tommy Bahama/rattan vibe. It’s also great for folks who want to do a little cooking, as all have full kitchens. Here kitties are part of the scenery, so this is not the pick for people allergic to cats.
Key West
Travel Guide
Key West› Hotel
Island City House Hotel
411 William St (btw. Eaton and Fleming Sts), Key West
Our Rating
Neighborhood
Around Town
Phone
800/634-8230, 305/294-5702
Prices
$230–$521 double
Amenities
Bike rental; concierge; access to nearby health club; outdoor heated pool; kitchen; free Wi-Fi
Units
24 units
Web site
Island City House Hotel
![2 star(s) 2 star rating](/assets/rating/fromm-rating-2star.png)
Map
411 William St Key WestNote: This information was accurate when it was published, but can change without notice. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before planning your trip.