North America / USA / New England / Massachusetts / Cape Cod, Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard / Nantucket / Best Restaurants

The Brotherhood of Thieves

The unusual name of this 1840s bar comes from an 1844 anti-slavery pamphlet written on Nantucket. It’s best for classic pub fare like burgers or even a fish burrito, washed down with craft beer (they have a couple dozen unusual ones available on tap and in bottles.)