Forget Nathans Hot Dogs! When you head to Coney Island, this is the treat to eat. Slinging perfect pies since 1924, Totonno's was out of commission after Hurricane Sandy for several months (scaring the life out of many of its fans, this one included). But it got its basement drained and its wood burning oven fired up once more, and today its putting out some of the most balanced, toothsome pizzas in the city. Be prepared for a wait, as this place is popular.