Don't expect to see big hotels or resorts on the North Fork. Instead, you'll find many motor inn-style spots dating from the 1950s; thankfully, the increased tourism of recent years has inspired some of these owners to renovate. One of the benefits of this part of the East End: You can actually stay right on the waterfront without remortgaging your own home.
You'll also find some fine B&Bs. In addition to the choices listed here, consider a stay at the light-drenched Shinn Estate Farmhouse, a 19th-century inn with modern decor and amenities, located on the Shinn Estate Vineyard, 2000 Oregon Rd., Mattituck (tel. 631/804-0367), or the waterfront Stirling House, 104 Bay Ave., Greenport (tel. 631/477-0654). Freddy's House, 1535 New Suffolk Rd., Cutchogue (tel. 631/734-4180), is a fully restored 18th-century farmhouse located on a working family-run farm. If you're in the market for a budget motel, try the old-school roadside Drosso's, 69125 Main Rd., Greenport (tel. 631/477-1334). While it's not on the water, it's a friendly place with an attached miniature golf course and outdoor snack bar.
Note: This information was accurate when it was published, but can change without notice. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before planning your trip.