This hotel has perhaps the best location in the city, right on historic Reynolds Square with room service from the Olde Pink House next door. Built in 1912, the inn lies on the historic site of John Wesley’s first parish in the 1730s. Rooms are simply but tastefully decorated with four-poster rice beds and fireplaces, though note that many overlook the parking garage and can be a little noisy—check before you settle in. Use of the nearby Lava 24 Fitness Center is complimentary for guests.