If you’re looking for a casual, friendly seafood spot right on the water, Fish Tails should nicely fit the bill. You’ll dine alfresco on a wooden deck overlooking Vessup Bay and its symphony of fishing boats. It’s open practically all day long, serving up island treats like shrimp and eggs (with potatoes) for breakfast and fish cake, seared tuna, grilled wahoo, and Caribbean lobster for lunch and dinner. It’s a nice place to bring the family, but it works well for a sunset cocktail, too—and it’s a local favorite for breakfast.