Once you're on the island, renting a car isn't necessary. To get where you're going, you can walk, bike, or take a golf cart or a taxi. Some restaurants outside the resort will send a shuttle to pick you up from your hotel. You likely won't need a cab except to get between the airport or ferry dock and your hotel. For details about taxi fares, call the Treasure Cay Airport Taxi Stand (tel. 242/365-8661). For a special occasion, call Elegante Limo Service (tel. 242/365-8248 or 365-8053), which charges $120 per hour for up to 10 passengers; this company also rents golf carts.
The only real reason to rent a car is for the 35-minute drive to Marsh Harbour to catch the ferries to Elbow Cay and Man-O-War Cay. If you decide to do so, Cornish Car Rental, at Treasure Cay Airport (tel. 242/365-8623), charges about $75 to $85 a day.
Wendell's Bicycle Rentals (tel. 242/365-8687), across from the bank in the Treasure Cay shopping center, rents beach cruisers (single-gear bikes with wide wheels) and mountain bikes for $10 to $15 a day or $45 per week. Four-seater electric golf carts go for $42 a day or $258 a week at either Wendell's or Claridge Golf Carts (tel. 242/365-8248 or 365-8053), just outside town.
Note: This information was accurate when it was published, but can change without notice. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before planning your trip.