Thank you for subscribing!
Got it! Thank you!

Due to the complexities of maintaining a neutral public space free of spam as well as potential liability issues stemming from proposed changes to digital communications law, we will be closing the Forums—but we will not be ending the conversation.

Your travel advice, questions, and stories will now continue to be shared at the Frommer’s Roamers Travel Chat group on Facebook.

We invite you to join the group today. On Facebook, go to @FrommersTravelGuides and click on “Groups” at the bottom of the lefthand menu. After you are approved as a member, please feel free to post questions and comments (no solicitations or advertisements).

To post to a group: From your News Feed, click “Groups” in the lefthand menu and select your group. Click on “Discussion,” then compose your post in the box that reads “Write something…”. Under "Chats," you can create a group chat.

We look forward to seeing you there!

advertisement

Forums » Books » I really like his take on guidebooks

Avatar

I really like his take on guidebooks

by /bio/phred »

Avatar

RE: I really like his take on guidebooks

by /bio/travel-rob »

Thanks Phred ,I enjoyed it as well.I even looked uo the Rick Steves blog he quoted.He said a lot of nice things about Arthur Frommer.

and I think Ricks view that both UGC and guidebooks have a place in market is right.

 

http://travelwriters.blogspot.com/2013/04/rick-steves-believes-printed-travel.html

 

 

Avatar
yostwl

RE: I really like his take on guidebooks

by yostwl »

While I love the internet for the ability to get detailed info on specific travel subjects, make reservations easily, etc., I still prefer a guidebook for overall planning.  The physical characteristics of the paper page in book form make it easier to complete some planning tasks compared to the internet.

I also sometimes get irritated with the PC-based library info systems.  Frequently when I want to find something, all the terminals are busy.  With the old card catalog system, seldom was anyone using the exact same card drawer that I needed to use.  But the PC systems are better for searching for something when you haven't a clue where to start.

Everything has its strong points and weak points.  Always a trade-off.

Avatar

RE: I really like his take on guidebooks

by /bio/phred »

The T&L article talks about using guidebooks AND the internet together, and that is the proper approach. As noted, each has its pluses and minuses.

I thought it interesting that the author after his experience writing guidebooks thinks they are vastly underpriced, and I'm not sure I don't agree.  But unfortunately they are a dying breed.

Avatar

RE: I really like his take on guidebooks

by /bio/joanna »

"...and that is the proper approach."  phred

I'd say the "proper" approach is the one that works best for an individual.  I'm sure there are plenty of travelers who use one OR the other or even neither and have what for them is a perfect trip.  We can only really say definitively what works for ourselves, (as some like to say) IMHO.

Avatar

RE: I really like his take on guidebooks

by /bio/scarlettcharlize »

This is a very interesting book that revolves around a crucially important discovery close to my own heart, this book is so interesting I am also writer at writing blogs and articles at Custom_Assignment

advertisement