Thank you for subscribing!
Got it! Thank you!

Travel Troubleshooter: Plenty of Rain, But No Raincheck for Leaky Hotel

What happens when a storm threatens to ruin a vacation, but the booking agent won't let you reschedule?

Jennifer Holland prepays for a hotel room on But a severe storm threatens to wash out her vacation. Holland wants the travel site to give her a rain check, but it won't, insisting its rooms are nonrefundable. She checks in, but finds her room is unusable. What, if anything, does Hotwire owe her?

Q: What happens when you've already paid for a hotel room but you can't stay in it?

I recently booked a weekend at The Ocean Club Beach Resort in Palm Beach, Fla., through Unfortunately, the weather took a turn for the worse the Friday before I was supposed to arrive, and we had heavy rains. I called Hotwire and asked if they would allow me to take a rain check for another weekend. I was told, "no."

So my friend and I drove down there in the storm. When we checked in, the power was out and the computer system was down. The "oceanfront" room we reserved was not available because of the rain leaking into the rooms and saturating the carpets. We were given a parking-lot view on the third floor. We went up to our floor and as we got off the elevator, it was about 80 degrees with a very bad odor, probably because of the power outage earlier that evening.

At 3:30am we were woken up by a leak coming from the ceiling to the bathroom. We ended up packing our belongings and going downstairs to check out of the hotel. When we got down to the lobby at about 4am, the ceiling in the lobby had a stream of water flowing from it, a terrible leak in the roof and there were three trashcans in the middle of the floor to catch the water.

I called American Express and asked them to dispute the room charge because of the weather and the condition of the hotel. I have also called the hotel manager directly to discuss this experience with him and he has failed to return any of my phone calls. American Express won't return my money. Can you help me? -- Jennifer Holland, Lake Mary, Fla.

A: Hotwire should have given you a rain check, not a refund.

Here's the thing about rooms booked through so-called "opaque" websites: You get a deep discount but you don't find out the name of the hotel until you pay. And your purchase is nonrefundable.

You knew that when you made your reservation. Sites like Hotwire make you check an "I've read the terms and conditions" box several times during the booking process to make double-sure you know you'll never see your money again.

But does Hotwire guarantee anything in return? Yes and no.

The website handles its hotels a lot like car rental companies handle their reservations. Which is to say, it offers a "class" of hotel based on a star rating, the same way a car rental company will reserve a class of vehicle.

There's an implied warranty that these properties will be up to standards, right? Not exactly.

Have a look at Hotwire's Terms of Use on its site, and it's clear that the company makes no promise that you can actually sleep in the room. Hotwire's contract says it makes no warranties of "satisfactory quality or fitness for a particular purpose," and the way I read it, that means it can sell you a nonrefundable room that's underwater.

Just as an aside, I wonder how many travelers actually take the time to read these dense legal contracts. If more did, would it affect where they booked their next trip?

I can understand why you would want to dispute your card charges, but that should be the next-to-last resort, before hiring an attorney. Contact the hotel first. Phoning the manager was a good idea, but you might have tried a letter or e-mail, too. You could have -- and should have -- also enlisted the help of Hotwire, who acted as your travel agent when you booked your room, and is supposed to be your advocate.

American Express was correct to deny your dispute. But Hotwire should have contacted the hotel when you called it, to find out if it was still accepting guests. I mean, how hard would it have been for the phone agent to look up the weather report and determine that the hotel is about to be ransacked by the mother of all storms?

I contacted Hotwire on your behalf, and it issued a voucher the equivalent of one night's stay at a different hotel. A spokesman also said Hotwire no longer sells rooms at The Ocean Club Beach Resort because the property is undergoing "extensive" renovations.

Christopher Elliott is the ombudsman for National Geographic Traveler magazine and the host of "What You Get For The Money: Vacations" on the Fine Living Network. E-mail him at

(c)2007 Christopher Elliott Distributed by Tribune Media Services, Inc.

Talk with other readers on our Online Reservations, Packagers & Tour Operators Message Boards.