Foxy’s oldest son (see previous recommendation) operates one of the liveliest spots on the island. Seddy Callwood and his wife, Raquel, have a loyal following, and the house policy of “No Shoes, No Shirt, No Problem” is said to have inspired Kenny Chesney’s hit song. The menu includes the catch of the day, kabobs, and tangy ribs—washed down with a knee-knocking Bushwhacker. One Love features live reggae music on Saturday and Sunday afternoons, but as soon as the sun sets, Seddy locks up and goes home.