North America / USA / Florida / South Florida / The Keys / Key West / Best Restaurants

Antonia’s

From the perfectly seasoned homemade focaccia to an exemplary Amaretto coconut cream pie, this elegant little standout is amazingly consistent. The menu includes a small selection of classics, linguine with shrimp, delicious pillowy gnocchi, and zuppa di pesce (fish soup), but it also does well with more inventive dishes like the warm goat-cheese soufflé appetizer. And you can’t go wrong with any of the handmade pastas. Bottom line: the food is great, but the atmosphere is a bit fussy for Key West. And if you don’t have a reservation in season, don’t even bother to stop by. This place books up months in advance.