Recommended Avalon options include the Bluewater Avalon (310/510-7494), a new American restaurant with some dock seating and a full bar. It's on the waterfront in the center of town, across from the Green Pleasure Pier. You will find locals at the Lobster Trap (310/510-8585; www.catalinalobstertrap.com), a casual seafood-and-cocktails joint, is a fun night out where the namesake dish is served so fresh that you can choose your dinner. Maggie's Blue Rose (310/510-3300; maggiesbluerose.com), facing the water, does freshly-made authentic Mexican with funky contemporary artworks and a full bar.
On the Two Harbors side of the island, the Harbor Reef Restaurant is the place to eat—literally. There's not a choice. Good thing it's not bad.
Note: This information was accurate when it was published, but can change without notice. Please be sure to confirm all rates and details directly with the companies in question before planning your trip.