This good-value gem sits high in the hills above Charlotte Amalie and its sparkling harbor—the views are splendid during the day but off-the-charts gorgeous at night. It has a congenial proprietor in Adam Israel, and the superb Mafolie Restaurant is one of the island’s best, a big proponent of the island’s farm-to-table movement with a menu featuring farm-grown produce and fresh-caught seafood. Each room is pleasantly furnished; none are swank by any means, in fact, some are on the smallish side, and a little dark, and a handful are only entered on the road side of the resort. But all are comfortable, with quality beds. Of the 22 rooms, 10 will have outdoor balconies by the time you read this, with those glittering harbor views at your feet, and five are suites. You can take a dip in the pool, which enjoys the same panoramic vista, or simply drink in the views at the pool bar.