Restaurants in St. Thomas, USVI
The dining scene in St. Thomas these days is among the best in the West Indies, but it has its drawbacks: Fine dining (and even not-so-fine dining) tends to be expensive, and the best spots (with a few exceptions) are actually not right in Charlotte Amalie and can be reached only by taxi or car.
You'll find an eclectic mix of cuisines on St. Thomas, including American, Italian, Mexican, Asian, and other options. We recommend exploring some of the local Caribbean dishes at least once or twice, especially the seafood specialties like "ole wife" and yellowtail, which are usually prepared with a spicy Creole mixture of peppers, onions, and tomatoes. The winner among native side dishes is fungi (pronounced foon-gee), made with okra and cornmeal. Most local restaurants serve johnnycake, a popular fried, unleavened bread.
On the Trail of Good Barbecue -- Locals will direct you to one of three locations for Texas Pit BBQ: the Charlotte Amalie Waterfront, Red Hook, or Seabay. The owners brought their secret barbecue recipe from Texas, where they learned how to make a fiery sauce to wake up your palate -- "and everything else," a habitué confided. These takeout stands are favored by yachties, St. Thomas cowboys, and frugal families. Chicken, tender ribs, and Texas-style beef are dished up in hearty portions, along with rice, coleslaw, and potato salad. One local pronounced these ribs the island's best. We tend to agree. The Waterfront joint, across from the Windward Passage Hotel on Veterans Drive, is open Monday to Saturday from 5:30 to 11pm; Red Hook, at the Red Hook Plaza, Monday to Saturday from 3 to 10pm; and Seabay, at the Nisky Center, Monday to Saturday from noon to 5:30pm. For information, call tel. 340/776-9579.
- Spanish
Amalia Café
Set on an alfresco terrace on Palm Passage in the center of Charlotte Amalie, this long-established spot serves up some of the most savory Spanish cuisine in town. You can order one of the hearty entrees (paella Valenciana, say, or zarzuela de mariscos, seafood casserole) or make a…$$$Charlotte Amalie - Seafood/Steak
Bleuwater
The Ritz’s showcase restaurant fashions elegant, creative turns on classic dishes. That might mean a lobster and truffle mac-n-cheese, or plantain gnocchi with Maine lobster and English peas. Fresh Virgin Islands seafood is highlighted—we devoured a pan-seared local Queen snapper…$$$East End - American
Bumpa’s
A deli-style joint, Bumpa’s is perfect when you want something simple but well-made. Many people, locals and visitors alike, stop in early in the morning to breakfast on terrific oatmeal banana pancakes, omelets, bagels, and lemonade. Lunch features burgers and sandwiches. Bumpa’s is…$Charlotte Amalie - Italian/Caribbean
Café Amici
A reliable spot for lunch during a shopping expedition in Charlotte Amalie’s historic district, Café Amici is located on an elevated patio in an old stone alley. It’s known for its creative brick-oven-baked pizzas (including a Caribbean jerk pizza and a crab-cake pizza with…$Charlotte Amalie - Deli
Frenchtown Deli
In addition to a full coffee bar, the Frenchtown Deli has some of the island’s best deli-style sandwiches, along with bagels and smoked salmon, homemade soups, and salads. Eat in or take out.$Frenchtown - Caribbean/American
Gladys’ Café
Dine on local favorites prepared to perfection at Gladys’s Café, a lively spot housed in a 1700 pump house smack-dab in the middle Charlotte Amalie’s historic district. It’s open for breakfast or lunch only. Sample jerk mahi-mahi, curry chicken roti, creamy conch chowder, and kalaloo…$$Charlotte Amalie - Cuban Fusion
Havana Blue
This Miami-style venue at the Marriott enjoys a beachfront ambience and an inspired menu. An inventive crew is in the kitchen, and out in the dining room, the party is rocking with sexy blue lights, a thumping soundtrack, and a bombshell bartenders serving up blueberry mojitos and…$$$The South Coast - American
Hook, Line & Sinker
This lively spot is set right on the water, with a New England seaport feel: whitewashed wood, French doors, and windows with shimmering harbor views. Well-prepared standards are the name of the game, such as steamed mussels, Caesar salad, or mushrooms stuffed with crabmeat and…$$Frenchtown - American/Continental
Iggies Beach Bar & Grill
This action-packed seaside grill is an island hot spot, but it’s also a fine place to take the family to dine. The menu features a plethora of pub-style appetizers plus steaks, ribs, and seafood, but every night is theme night; Wednesday is Cruzan Carnival Night, with a Caribbean…$$$The South Coast - Caribbean/International
Mafolie Restaurant
This is one of the island’s top restaurants—and you get your money’s worth, from the terrific island fare to the breathtaking views of the Charlotte Amalie harbor below from the open-air dining room. The Caribbean specialties include a classic kalaloo soup, here brimming with shrimp,…$$$Charlotte Amalie - Global/Island
Oceana
This buzzy local favorite is ensconced in the restored West Indian great house of an estate known as Villa Olga, which served as the island’s Russian embassy in the late 1800s. It’s right on the water’s edge, with sweeping views of the Charlotte Amalie harbor. Inside the walls are…$$$Frenchtown - West Indian/International
Petite Pump Room
Join the locals for a reliably tasty St. Thomas breakfast and lunch at this second-floor harborside spot in the ferryboat terminal in Charlotte Amalie. Located on the harbor since 1970, it serves some of the island’s most flavorful West Indian cooking, with a menu of callaloo greens,…$$$Charlotte Amalie - Pizza
Señor Pizza
If you’re burned out on conch (and even if you’re not), you’ll be quite satisfied with the big, cheesy pizza pies served at Senor Pizza. Slices are oversized, so one might be all you need for a tasty, filling lunch. They also deliver.$East End - American
Sunset Grille
This may be the island’s best new restaurant, with a waterside setting that’s both breezy and seductive, and a menu with plenty of flavorful turns. Such as the prawns tempura, lightly fried shrimp in a sweet soy glaze served on long skewers, or the tomato-based conch chowder (a…$$$East End - Modern European/Caribbean
Tavern of Charlotte Amalia
How’s this for a global mashup: a nightclub/restaurant that serves comfort dishes with West Indies inflections in a glittering setting on the St. Thomas waterfront. Sounds odd, but it works. So you might pinball from Polish pierogies to garlic escargots to jerk chicken to baby back…$$$Charlotte Amalie - Seafood/West Indian
The Caribbean Fish Market
Breezy and bright, this indoor/outdoor seafood eatery sits right on the beach at the Elysian Beach Resort, looking out onto the sapphire seas of Cowpet Bay. It’s also right next door to the Ritz-Carlton, making it a very convenient place for Ritz guests to enjoy a solid seafood…$$$East End - International
The Old Stone Farmhouse
Set in the centuries-old field house of a restored Danish sugar plantation, the newly revitalized Old Stone Farmhouse is a special-occasion treat. Part of the fun is visiting the kitchen to pick out your meat or fish and hobnob with the chefs. But it’s just a kitchen, after all;…$$$North of Charlotte Amalie - Italian
Virgilio’s
The best Italian restaurants on island, Virgilio’s serves up Sicilian classics and homemade pastas and risottos, including a hearty “Lasagna de Maria,” from a Virgilio family recipe. You can also get traditional veal and chicken dishes, as well as a sprinkling of fresh-made pizzas,…$$$Charlotte Amalie
