Pauline Frommer
North America / USA / New York State / New York City / Best Hotels

Hotel St. James

My award for most improved hotel goes to this Times Square stalwart. The St. James spent the pandemic renovating and cleaning, and then continued that process in the years since. It shows. The hotel hasn’t become fashionable or plush—furnishings are still all mass-produced and the mattresses are hard—but it hasn’t become pricey or added resort fees, either. Expect spotless and highly functional guest quarters, with a hair more elbow room than usual, closets, private bathrooms, and shades that keep out the light. Tip: You'll pay far less if you book directly on the St. James website, rather than on third party sites.